Handy Manny:Latino Role Model or Stereotype _ CLIP 9

Posted on Monday 4 September 2006

icon for podpress  Handy Manny: Latino Role Model or Stereotype?: Play Now | Play in Popup | Download

Handy Manny: Latino Role Model or Stereotype?

In this show: Happy Birthday to Andrea and Lucy, Tools for thinking about Disney’s “Handy Manny”

Special Thanks to : Kevan Miller for the station ID.

Music: Happy Birthday by Craymo

Podcasts Mentioned: Just One More Book

Websites Mentioned: Latin_Know, Vivir Latino

Participate in the show.

Subscribe and listen in iTunes

XML Feed Location : feed://www.bazmakaz.com/clip/?feed=rss2

Let me know where you are by clicking on ‘Join the CLIP Frappr Map’ in the menu bar.

Post a comment by clicking the comment button below or leave a voice mail by clicking ‘leave me a message’ in the menu bar or by calling 206-339-CLIP(2547) or e-mailing at clippodcast@gmail.com

Produced by Andy Bilodeau

To read the show transcript click on ‘more’ below.

Show #9 Transcript
How’s it going? It’s good to have you back on Show #9 of the clip Podcast. As always I’d like to start off by acknowledging those of you who have commented on the show or contributed to the show. Thank you to Kathleen Fay and Kevan Miller in particular for their support and for contributing station IDs which I will air in the next couple of shows and the Bailey’s Critical Literacy Study Group for contributing to a future show.

I also want to say hello to Carolyn Burke in Bloomington Indiana who recently had double knee replacement surgery…I’m thinking of you Carolyn.

Finally, belated birthday greetings to Andrea of the Just One More Book Podcast as well as her daughter Lucy.

Happy Birthday by craymo

Today I’d like to focus on a new show being released by the folks at Disney in the next couple of weeks…Handy Manny.

Station ID
Midtro
Music Bumper

Have you heard of Handy Manny?

Gary Marsh, President, of Disney Channel Worldwide states “Handy Manny is an exciting addition to our preschool programming line-up, offering an authentic multicultural perspective, humor, and valuable messages about friendship, community and working together,”. “Led by Wilmer Valderrama , Fez on that 70’s show, it is rich with creativity, heart and intelligence. Preschoolers, parents and caregivers the world over are sure to embrace this unique new series.”

Disney claims that “Handy Manny” is designed to infuse preschool viewers with the confidence to take on challenges and try to work them out, most notably interpersonal relationships. Playful and filled with humor and quirky, relatable characters, the episodes reinforce core early-learning concepts while also emphasizing pro-social and emotional themes including getting along with friends and family, helping others, and trying one’s best.

Disney further claims that,
“Handy Manny” teaches preschoolers simple Spanish words and phrases by putting them into a real-world context - such as Manny saying “abuelito” when referring to his grandfather. In addition, the series introduces everyday aspects of Latino culture, including certain holidays and the importance of family. “Handy Manny” will also resonate with young Latino viewers, thanks to its authentic portrayal of culturally-relevant characters and customs.

Now, of course I’m really hoping that this show is able to do all that Disney claims it is capable of doing…time will tell. So let’s keep tabs on the show and see how it unfolds.

From what I’ve Googled in each episode someone contacts Manny the Handyman to do some repair work at which time Manny formulates a plan of action and gets to work. While doing this work he apparently relies heavily on his helpers, a bunch of talking tools. There is Pat a bumbling Hammer, Turner a grumpy screwdriver, Felipe an ambitious screwdriver, Dusty who plays the role of the maternal Saw, Stretch a perfectionist tape measure. Then there is Rusty a fearful Wrench, and Squeeze, a curious pair of pliers.

If you or your kids or kids you know happen to watch the show, here are some things I’m wondering about that may offer you a perspective on viewing the show.

The first thing I’m wondering is whether the show is simply a new take on a long-standing stereotype?

I’m also thinking about what it would mean to read or view the show through the lens of an existing show. I’m thinking here in particular about Bob the Builder. If you rub one show up against the other for instance you’ll notice that where Manny, a latino character, has a cast of tools that fit into a tool box, Bob, a white character, has a construction company filled with machinery and equipment. Handy Manny’s theme song focuses on the phrase “we’ll fix it right” or something close to that while Bob’s theme song asks the question “Can we build it”…the reponse being.. “Yes We Can”.

There is also an interesting comment cross-posted on Vivir Latino and Latin_Know that you could use to read or view the show. I’ll link to these sites on the shownotes.

Here’s what the post says,

Why is that television believes children can get down with Spanish while adults cannot? For whatever reason, prime time TV (with rare exceptions like Freddie Prinze’s “Freddie”) doesn’t want to bother with bilingualism, even though Latinos are a perfect demographic: 600 billion in buying power, median age of 26, average household size of 4 members, yadayadayada…

There’s a huge rise in the use of Spanish and bilingual dialogues in mainstream children’s television programming. We’ve posted before about Dora La Exploradora, but she’s not alone.

But now PBS Kids’ has more Latino offerings. ‘’Dragon Tales'’ was revamped last year to highlight Latino issues and include Enrique, an immigrant who is Puerto Rican and Colombian. ‘’Jay Jay the Jet Plane'’ added a new bilingual plane named Lina.

At a time when Freddy Prinze’s dad was the only “bilingual” character on TV, “Sesame Street” was emerging as the only multi-cultural option for children. The same seems to be happening now. Why?

Census 2000 showed that Latino communities are the nation’s fastest growing — and the biggest five-year Latino age group is infants to preschoolers.

Next time you think about how liberating it is that your kids have more Latino cartoons to watch, think also about whose dollars they are after: yours via your children. Smarter than targeting you outright, no?

So hopefully I’ve left you with some tools or perspectives with which to view the show.

Outro

Tags :Technorati , , , , , , , , ,

9 Comments for 'Handy Manny:Latino Role Model or Stereotype _ CLIP 9'

  1.  
    Rosary Lalik
    September 5, 2006 | 2:55 pm
     

    I just listened to the show (9) and enjoyed it very much. I especially liked the questions you offered as frames for listening to the children\’s show, Handy Manny. They made me think that being handy is certain okay in this society, but it is certainly not among the characteristics that influential individuals typically aspire to achieve. This make me think that Manny could have been creative, highly skilled in solving problems, or a person who could explain complicated ideas.

    I look forward to further podcasts.

  2.  
    Vivian
    September 5, 2006 | 2:59 pm
     

    Hi Rosary! Thanks for both the voice message and comment! I’m glad you found the questions useful and that you are able to use the show in your class. The show is my attempt to create space for talking about and exploring critical literacy so I hope you and your students find it useful in that way.

    I too look forward to keeping connected!

  3.  
    September 5, 2006 | 8:46 pm
     

    Hi Vivian,

    Another great, thought provoking show. Tuesdays are always so tough because I can see the show notes (at work) but have to wait till after 8pm to actually listen!

    And thank you so much for the birthday wishes! What a treat for Lucy and me!

    Once again, I’m out of the pop culture loop and hadn’t even heard of Handy Manny so I don’t have an opinion on this week’s topic. Being a software designer by day, however, I know how much more difficult it can be to troubleshoot a problem, pinpoint the cause and piece together a workable solution than it is to build an entire system from scratch. As Rosary mentioned, above, this fixit work requires high levels of creativity, intelligence, persistence and problem solving skills and yet the people who do this valuable work are often in the shadow of those who produce huge volumes of code (which the fixit people will later fix!). We are aware of this, yet we continue to value those who build from scratch more than we value those who solve our problems. I wonder why that is.

    Thanks again for CLIP! It keeps me thinking.
    Andrea

  4.  
    Vivian
    September 6, 2006 | 12:16 am
     

    Thank you for such thoughtful comments Andrea and Rosary. You both have given us more to think about regarding what/who is deemed more valuable and therefore privileged in society and how that happens along with what dominant discourses and ideologies work to maintain this.

    I think our exchanges are important in pushing all our thinking so I appreciate very much the time you’ve taken to post comments! :-)

    I’ll keep my fingers crossed for Just One More Book to broadcast again soon Andrea!

    Thank You!
    vivian

  5.  
    Tara
    September 11, 2006 | 8:53 pm
     

    I enjoyed listening to show (9). I watch Dora the Explorer from time to time, so I will make an attempt to watch “Handy Manny”. Dora the Explorer is enjoyable because she teaches the viewers many things. I believe she is a positive role model for young viewers. In response to your question, I do believe that the show does have a stereotypical undertone to it. Nonetheless, I am glad to know that “Handy Manny” does deal with character building.

  6.  
    Vivian
    September 11, 2006 | 9:34 pm
     

    Thanks for commenting Tara. I look forward to hearing your thoughts after watching the show.

  7.  
    Heather
    September 14, 2006 | 4:19 pm
     

    I love Dora the Explorer, and yes Handy Manny is a little unoriginal in a couple of aspects, but I strongly believe that Handy Manny will still be a good show for kids, and if any of you once watched ‘That’s 70’s Show’ then you’ll be happy to know that Wilmer Valderrama who played ‘Fez’ is going to voice ‘Manny’ on Handy Manny.

  8.  
    Vivian
    September 14, 2006 | 11:19 pm
     

    I’m certainly hoping that it turns out to be a good show for kids. Wilmer Valderama has actually been doing all sorts of promos for the show with his little brother who I believe may be doing some things on the show as well.

  9.  
    Gordon Shumway
    July 26, 2008 | 12:49 pm
     

    Since ethnic stereotyping in children’s programming is now acceptable, how about a show featuring an Indian immigrant who teaches children how to buy out hotel and gas station chains? You could call it “Motel Patel”. And wait until you hear about “Jobless Jerome”…

Leave a comment

(required)

(required)


Information for comment users
Line and paragraph breaks are implemented automatically. Your e-mail address is never displayed. Please consider what you're posting.

Use the buttons below to customise your comment.


RSS feed for comments on this post |